Here is additional information, along with the research sources, for the questions in the Quiz members of Appleton Concerned Taxpayers distributed to members of the Common Council earlier this year.
- According to the City of Appleton Finance Department, your 2025 real estate taxes were distributed 41% to the City, 37% to the Appleton Area School District, 16% to Outagamie County, and 4% to Fox Valley Technical College. https://appletonwi.gov/government/departments/finance/real_estate_taxes.php. Note: Property tax amounts in Appleton vary because the city spans three counties (Outagamie, Calumet, and Winnebago) and includes multiple overlapping school districts and special assessment/taxing districts.
- According to the former director of the City of Appleton Finance Department, in 2022 the average homeowner paid $434 a year in interest for the city’s debt obligations. That figure has increased since 2022.
- In 2025, Appleton’s general obligation debt totaled $93,781,180 (https://appletonwi.gov/government/departments/finance/budgets.php#undefined, page vii). In 2015, general obligation debt totaled $31,535,000 (https://emma.msrb.org/ES971503.pdf, page 19). Thus, the amount of G.O. debt tripled in 10 years.
- According to an AI overview drawing from multiple sources, “Appleton’s city government represents about 1% of the city’s total energy-related GHG emissions, with wastewater treatment dominating the municipal share.” (https://www.bing.com/search?q=appleton+city+government+represents+about+1%25+of+the+city%27s+energy+profile&cvid=54189364ae274dde9707115f02c1bbbc&gs_lcrp=EgRlZGdlKgYIABBFGDkyBggAEEUYOTIGCAEQRRhAMgcIAhDrBxhA0gEJMTI3ODFqMGo0qAIIsAIB&FORM=ANAB01&adppc=EDGEESS&PC=DCTS). The sustainability consulted noted our city government is only about 1% of the total energy profile of the city. Changes to the way city government operates won’t make a huge dent in the overall energy consumption of the city.
- According to an analysis by the Wisconsin Legislative Council, obtained and explained by the MacIver Institute, a TID increases property taxes for taxpayers outside the TID for the length of the TID (16-20 years). https://www.maciverinstitute.com/news/your-property-tax-bill-is-higher-because-of-tif-districts-legislative-council-confirms
- According to an AI overview, “TID #3 did face significant hurdles:
A $15.4 million valuation drop from 2009–2010 due to state valuation methodology changes and a bankruptcy sale at Richmond Terrace. The district was designated “distressed” in 2011, extending its life by 10 years to 2029. By 2020, 13 undervalued parcels still had redevelopment potential but could not be improved because the expenditure period ended in 2014. (https://cms2.revize.com/revize/appletonwi/Documents/CommDev/Economic%20Development/TIDs/TID%203%20Project%20Plan.pdf)
TID #10 failure (Source: City of Appleton)
The “failure” of Appleton’s Tax Incremental District (TID) #10 refers to its long-term struggle to attract private redevelopment, leaving major commercial sites vacant and blighted for over a decade.
Created in 2013, TID 10 covers the north side of the West College Avenue corridor from Lilas Drive to Linwood Avenue. Although designed to incentivize developers to revitalize this key gateway into the city, it has faced compounding private-market stagnation.
Key Stagnant and Vacant Sites
According to the city’s 2027 Executive Budget and Capital Program, several prime locations within the district remain undeveloped:
- The Former K-Mart Site: The 12-acre property – the largest vacant parcel in the district – was demolished in 2008 and remains completely empty.
- The Marketplace Commercial Center: Built in 1964, the largest building in TID 10 continues to plague the area with severe, multi-year vacancies.
- The Vacant CVS Pharmacy: A 17,000-square-foot building has remained unoccupied since CVS moved out in 2009.
- The Empty Shopko Lot: The city has spent years in talks with the property owners, but no projects have gotten off the ground.
Understanding Tax Incremental Districts (TID) and Tax Incremental Financing (TIF)
While often used interchangeably, a Tax Incremental District (TID) and Tax Incremental Financing (TIF) have distinct meanings. Tax Incremental Districts (TIDs) and Tax Incremental Financing (TIF) collectively are economic development tools used by local governments to promote development and redevelopment, thus stimulating growth in carefully targeted areas.
A Tax Incremental District (TID) is a specific geographic area within a city or village that is targeted for development or economic revitalization (there are special statutes governing town TIDs). It is usually an underdeveloped or blighted area that requires improvements to infrastructure, public facilities, or private development to reach its highest and best use. In other words, “but for” the establishment of the TID, the desired development would not be achieved by the market alone. This is called the “but for” test. (edwc.org)
- Since 2016, Appleton’s assessed valuations have increased about 59% (Outagamie County), and 52% (Winnebago and Calumet County). According to an AI summary, Appleton property assessments have experienced a dramatic shift since 2016, with a 59% cumulative increase closely matching the average baseline for many residential properties following the city’s major revaluation efforts. See also for alternative estimates: https://cms2.revize.com/revize/appletonwi/Documents/CommDev/Assessor/Tax%20Rate%20and%20Assessment%20Chart.pdf
- The City of Appleton’s 2027 budget shifts expenses away from property taxes by having those paid for by the wheel tax, a quarterly charge for trash bins, and requirement for the purchase of recycling bins (https://www.nbc26.com/appleton/appletons-224-million-budget-raises-questions-about-costs-for-residents), as well as fire pit inspection fees and a fire fee. (https://applications.appleton.org/departments/fire/onlinepermits/firepermit.aspx)
Permit Types and Fees
- Daily (Single Use): $15.00 (Requires Inspection)
- Seasonal (New):$30.00 (Valid January 1 – December 31; Requires Inspection)
- Seasonal (Renewal):$30.00 (Valid January 1 – December 31)
Although the city’s Finance Committee recommended not increasing the wheel tax from $20 to $30, the City Council approved doing so in June 2024. (https://fox11online.com/news/local/appleton-common-council-wheel-tax-increase-2025-30-dollars-road-street-maintenance)
- The city’s Mission Statement is provided on page 2 of the City of Appleton 2027 Budget and Service Plan. (https://appletonwi.gov/government/departments/finance/budgets.php#undefined)
- According to the Tax Foundation, Wisconsin ranked 10th highest in property tax rates in 2024. Wisconsin ranks 9th highest in the United States for its effective property tax rate, according to recent U.S. Census Bureau data compiled by Property Tax Rates by State.
In February 2026, WalletHub ranked Wisconsin 43rd in lowest property taxes paid for value of home rankings.
BONUS QUESTION
According to the City of Appleton’s Department of Public Works, the regressive wheel tax of $30/vehicle/year covers 36% of Appleton’s road reconstruction.
“While the elimination of special assessments is generally regarded as a positive change for residents, the funding that program once provided for roads, sidewalks, and infrastructure has not been replaced. Instead, a regressive City-wide wheel tax was imposed and collects a fraction of the total needed to appropriately maintain our City. As a result, beginning in 2016, new G.O. debt issues increased significantly as the cost of infrastructure maintenance was layered on top of the projects traditionally funded through G.O. debt.” (Mayor’s Budget Letter, p https://appletonwi.gov/government/departments/finance/budgets.php#undefined, page vi.)
