DPI’s rankings mislead parents by rating poverty over performance
Delafield, Wis. – The Department of Public Instruction has rated 0 districts 1 star on the 2026 state report cards. DPI rated 52% of scored schools 4 or 5 stars.
DPI released the results November 17.
The Quote
“We all know DPI has lowered the bar for students. But DPI also does not give high-performing, high-poverty schools the credit they deserve.” said Quinton Klabon, Senior Research Director at the Institute for Reforming Government. “Choosing a school is among the biggest moments in a parent’s life, and DPI’s report cards do nothing to help them.”
Dig Deeper
DPI’s report cards are the worst of both worlds.
-
DPI has watered down standards.
-
There is not a single 1-star district in all of Wisconsin, not even low performers like Beloit, Menominee, or Milwaukee.
-
DPI rated more schools 4 or 5 stars than in 2025. This is despite Harvard University ranking Wisconsin 33rd of 38 states in mathematics recovery and 30th of 35 states in reading recovery.
-
-
DPI punishes high-performing, high-poverty schools. Economic disadvantage correlates 54% with report card score, the opposite of what state report cards are supposed to do.
-
Districts like Janesville, Sheboygan, and Prairie Du Chien far exceed expectations for high-poverty districts, but DPI rates them a mere 3 stars.
-
DPI denied 5 stars to Milwaukee superstar schools like Hmong-American Peace, Saint Josaphat Catholic, Saint Augustine Christian, Bruce Guadalupe, Salam Islamic, and Saint John’s Lutheran.
-
